The 7 Best Graco Pack ‘n’ Play Mattresses to Buy in 2019

Graco Pack ‘n Play and Playard portable cribs are great for families with babies to toddlers. They provide a safe place for the little ones to sleep and play away from home, in the backyard, or while visiting.

In this review, we found the best mattresses for Graco Pack ‘n Play products.

Let’s dive in…

2-Minute Buyers’ Guide

Every choice you make in buying for baby is crucial. What seems like an easy option, say, the dimensions of a mattress may mean a too small fit for the play yard or portable crib. That gap at the edges is a real danger to the baby. Here are some of the information parents need before buying a replacement mattress or topper for the Graco Pack ‘n Play Portable Cribs and Playards.

Safety Above All

Babies need our protection every minute. The most dangerous time is any time a baby is asleep. We all fear the tragedy of SIDS, Sudden Infant Death Syndrome. Buying the right mattress and using it correctly can help protect our little ones. The U.S. Consumer Product Safety Commission has been proactive for years in giving parents the guidance they need. Remember the advice of the CPSC, the ABCs of safe sleep: Alone on the Back in a bare Crib. Don’t use sleep positioners, special head contour devices, pillows, blankets, bolsters, or allow toys in the crib or play yard. Keep it fun, keep it comfortable, and, above all, keep it safe.

The Right Age

Pack n’ Play portable cribs can really be used with any baby up to 18 months, or when they decide to climb out and explore on their own. When our little Leila was born, when Keane and I lived in a tiny apartment that didn’t allow room for a real crib. She slept in a Pack n’ Play portable crib until she was four months old. It worked great and fulfilled a real need at the time. One more thing, watch older siblings. They are quite attracted to the idea of climbing into the bed to visit with baby.

Important Features

There is a host of information on features. Sometimes, it can be difficult to keep the data straight and focus in on the real issues. Here are the ones we think you will want to consider and why they are important in your search.

  • The Right Cover
    There is a range of covers over the mattresses. I would recommend carefully considering how you intend to use the bed. Some covers are organic cotton, unzippable, and washable. That sounds great until you think about all the constant liquid messes babies can produce. What happens when that mess soaks into a foam core? You aren’t going to be able to machine wash that!A cotton cover may work fine if you use an impermeable protector between the sheet and the mattress. Other mattresses have protection against spills that even extends to the thread they use in the cover construction.
  • The Right Construction
    There are fabric and foam choices. Each has advantages and drawbacks. Here is another decision that demands serious consideration. After all, no one wants to have to buy another mattress. What features are important to you? These differences make a difference in weight, safety, and lifetime of the mattress. There’s no right choice for everyone. Whatever your needs are, there is a replacement mattress in the market that’s good for your family.
  • The Right Size
    Not all mattresses fit all portable Graco products. There are many Graco Pack n’ Play and Playards. Some of our mattress choices below have 90-degree corners for squared spaces, or rounded corners that fit more styles. Always, always, buy a replacement mattress that is large enough for the product. If necessary, buy the next size larger.It is quite unsafe for a baby to sleep in a crib that has a space between the mattress and the edge of the Playard. When you buy sheets to fit, match them to the corner requirements of the mattress. Rounded corner sheets will fit more sizes. Always make sure the sheet is very tight on the mattress.
  • Special Features
    One of the most useful special features is the tri-fold construction. The tri-fold means that when you lift it out of crib, the mattress has two folding lines. You can quickly flip it into a neat package. The feature makes hefting the mattress easier. As a bonus, folded in this way, the mattress becomes a nice place to sit when the baby grows into a toddler.The second bonus feature is a travel bag. When you travel to hotels or the houses of relatives and friends, it is nearly essential that the mattress have a container. A bag with a handle makes it simpler to move, cleaner while traveling, and far neater looking.

Our Top Picks

Here is our list of the eight best mattresses for Graco Pack ‘n Play products. They represent a variety of mattresses and toppers that you can use to replace one that is worn out or just not working for you.

#1 Dream On Me 3″ Playard Mattress

Best Waterproof Crib Mattress for Graco Pack ‘n Play

This Dream On Me (check price on Amazonreplacement mattress for the Graco Playard features a unique waterproof cover. While it doesn’t look as cozy as some covers, it serves an important purpose. It keeps all diaper leaks, drooling, and upchucks away from the mattress below.

Even the stitching is antibacterial and lock-stitched with waterproof binding. You can quickly clean the mattress with mild soap and water. The mattress meets all Federal standards and GREENGUARD Gold Certified.

For Ages: 6 months +
For Weights: 3 – 45 pounds
Cover: Non-allergenic, anti-bacterial waterproof; wipe clean
Product Construction: Vinyl 10 percent; Foam 90 percent
Dimensions: 37.5 X 25.5 X 3 inches (squared corners)
Product Weight: 3.5 pounds

What They’ll Love:

  • No leaking, mold, or mildew danger
  • Easily cleaned

Check Price on Amazon

#2 LA Baby Waterproof Portable/Mini Crib Mattress

This 2-inch LA Baby mattress (check price on Amazon) is filled with a high-density polyfiber and has a vinyl cover that is washable with mild soap and water. The cover has a dust-mite barrier, is antimicrobial, hypoallergenic, and non-toxic. Made in the USA from domestic and imported sources. This LA Baby mattress is covered by a one-year warranty.

For Ages: NL
For Weights: 7 – 36 pounds
Cover: Waterproof Vinyl
Product Construction: High-Density Polyfiber
Dimensions: 24 X 38 X 2 inches
Product Weight: 4 pounds

What They’ll Love:

  • Non-allergenic, anti-bacterial waterproof; wipe clean
  • One-year warranty

Check Price on Amazon

#3 NapYou Amazon Exclusive Pack ‘n Play Mattress

This mattress (check price on Amazonreplacement comes as a tri-fold with a travel bag with handle. This makes it easier to move from home to grandma’s house. Junior can also use the mattress on the living room floor as a play mat. This mattress is constructed with a MEMORY FOAM core with an organic cotton and polyester cover. The foam makes the mattress relatively heavy. Without an impermeable barrier, there is a chance that leaks can go through to the mattress.

For Ages: NL
For Weights: NL
Cover: 40 percent Organic Cotton, 60 percent Polyester (machine washable)
Product Construction: MEMORY FOAM
Dimensions: 37.5 x 26 x 1.5 inches (rounded corners)
Product Weight: 6.46 pounds

What They’ll Love:

  • Tri-fold with carry bag makes travel easy

Watch For:

  • Leaks may go through cover to the mattress
  • Mattress is rather thin at 1-1/2 inches

Check Price on Amazon

#4 Pack N Play Mattress Pad Cover Protector

Best Budget Buy

If you have a mattress (check price on Amazonthat allows leaks from diapers, bottles, and drooling to soak into the core, you’ll want to invest in a mattress pad cover that stops all that. We learned that hard lesson after Dara’s sippy cup came undone. Four ounces of apple juice came raining down. We bought a new mattress and a good waterproof cover; lesson learned. This cover has three layers. The top is a Microfiber filled with polyester. Next, there is a waterproof membrane made of thermoplastic polyurethane (TPU) that protects their exclusive heat protection layer from melting in the dryer. The cover is machine washable and dryable and will not shrink.

For Ages: NL
For Weights: 5 – 40 pounds
Cover: NA
Product Construction: Washable
Dimensions: 52 x 28 x 9 inches (rounded corner skirting)
Product Weight: 11.4 ounces

What They’ll Love:

  • Waterproof
  • Heat protection layer

Check Price on Amazon

#5 Milliard Tri-Fold Pack N’ Play Mattress

This Milliard tri-fold mattress (check price on Amazon) is made with a 2-inch MEMORY FOAM core. The cover is waterproof and is 65 percent cotton. The cover is removable and can be washed and dried in your machines. This construction neatly solves the issue of the ease of washable cotton versus the protection of waterproofing. The mattress is thin enough to keep the weight manageable and thick enough to provide comfort for baby. The tri-fold is a good option for traveling and use throughout the house as baby grows.

For Ages: NL
For Weights: NL
Cover: Waterproof 65 percent cotton zipper cover
Product Construction: 2-inch Memory Foam
Dimensions: 13 x 7 x 7 inches
Product Weight: 3 pounds

What They’ll Love:

  • Balances comfort and portability
  • Waterproof cover

Check Price on Amazon

#6 Milliard Memory Foam Mini Crib Mattress

Best Folding Mattress for Graco Pack n’ Play

The Milliard mattress (check price on Amazon) is made of high-density MEMORY FOAM and CertiPUR-US certified. It has medium-firm foam to provide safe breathing space for the youngest babies. Milliard designed the mattress to provide both comfort and protection. The waterproof cover is 65 percent cotton and zips off for washing and drying. Although the cover is fabric, an inverted laminating process prevents liquids from soaking through to the core.

For Ages: NL
For Weights: NA
Cover: Waterproof 65 percent cotton zipper cover
Product Construction: High-Density Memory Foam
Dimensions: 38 x 24 x 2 inches
Product Weight: 4.5 pounds

What They’ll Love:

  • Soft cover with waterproof protection
  • Firm foam for breathability

Check Price on Amazon

#7 MamaDoo Kids Smart Play Yard Mattress Topper

This tri-fold mattress (check price on Amazon) topper is also a versatile play mat. Changing station? Got it covered. It can handle naps and even serve as a bench for a toddler when you fold it up. The core is foam with a washable cotton fabric cover. It is available in several colors and a travel bag is included. Conforms to the requirements of the Consumer Products Safety Commission and Consumer Product Safety Improvement Acts.

For Ages: NL
For Weights: NL
Cover: Washable Cotton
Product Construction: High-Density Foam
Dimensions: 26 x 37.5 x 1.5 inches
Product Weight: 2.3 pounds

What They’ll Love:

  • Versatile
  • Folds and packs in bag for travel

Check Price on Amazon

And the winner is…

Dream On Me 3″ Playard Mattress (check price on Amazon) is our selection for the best mattress for Graco Pack ‘n Play products. It is thick enough at 3 inches to be comfortable. The Dream On Me company has gone to great lengths to produce a watertight cover with easy cleaning. It ticks all the boxes we set out.

Leave a Reply

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

Pin It on Pinterest

Share This