The 10 Best Teething Toys to buy in 2019

There’s a lot of joys to be experienced in baby’s first year of life, but it’s a rare parent who’d list teething among them.

There’s no getting out of dealing with it, but choosing the right teething toys can make the experience a little less painful for both you and your baby.

It’s natural to be concerned about making a great pick – after all, this is something that goes into your baby’s mouth – so we investigated 10 great options to help you find the best teething toy for your baby.

Editor's Choice

Nuby Silicone Teethe-EEZ Teether

The Nuby Silicone Teether comes with bristles which are great for stimulating and soothing your baby’s sore gums as teeth are erupting.

View on Amazon

Is it important to use teething toys for babies?

While it’s not technically essential to use a teething toy, parents know the drill. Teething babies will find something to chew on, and if you can redirect them to something healthy and hygienic that offers them some legitimate comfort, that’s a big win. Wondering why teething toys are a good option?

  • They’re designed to promote oral health: Unlike other objects your baby might try to gum on, teething toys are designed to gently soothe and stimulate their sore gums without breaking the skin. They’re also easy to sanitize, protecting baby from bacteria and germs.
  • They’re made of materials that are safe for your baby: When you give your baby a quality teething toy, you can feel confident that the material is safe for them to put in their mouth and isn’t treated with chemicals. Their other toys aren’t made for biting, and toys like plastic stacking rings that look like teethers may not be safe.
  • They’re just the right size for baby: The best teething toys are designed to be easy for babies to grab and hold. They’re also too big to be a choking hazard, which is a big concern when babies start reaching for things to put in their mouths.

How can I make sure that the teething toys I’m giving my baby are safe?

Safety is always our first priority, which means being sure that toys and gear are safe before they come anywhere near kids. When it comes to teething toys, there are two major factors that determine whether a pick is safe: the material it’s made of and how big it is.

Material: Since a teething toy goes into your baby’s mouth, it goes without saying that it must be non-toxic. That means avoiding dangerous materials like BPA as well as Phthalates, which are usually found in PVC. These chemicals are linked to the development of asthma and allergies and may cause endocrine and neurobehavioral developmental issues.

Size: It’s important that teething toys be larger than your baby’s mouth, because this makes the toy impossible for them to choke on. Any toy, teething or otherwise, that doesn’t fit this criteria should be considered a choking hazard that’s not safe for children under three.

What are some remedies I can use to help my baby with teething?

Of course, teething toys are far from the only remedy to soothe sore gums. It’s not exactly a new problem, so spates of “age-old” home remedies get tossed around a lot. Not all of these are a good idea, so save your good whiskey for after bedtime and check out some teething remedies that really work.

  • Gently massage your baby’s gums: With either clean hands or a wet washcloth or gauze pad, use one finger to gently apply pressure to your baby’s gums. It can help to ease their pain a bit.
  • Use pain relief: Fortunately for parents, there’s trusted pain relievers available that are made in safe doses for our little ones. Children’s Tylenol or Motrin are good picks, but let your pediatrician make the final call.
  • Freeze a washcloth: A simple washcloth can offer a lot of comfort to a teething baby. Wet a clean washcloth and ring it out thoroughly, then fold it up into a square and put it in a plastic zipper bag. Freeze it for a few hours, then remove the washcloth from the bag and let your baby knaw on it. Make sure you wash the washcloth between each use to get rid of bacteria and debris.

One remedy to avoid? Teething tablets, some of which contain belladonna, a plant that’s not safe for babies – or anyone, really – to consume. It’s also known as nightshade, the pretty but dangerous berry your parents and camp counselors reminded you many times to never, ever eat.

Our Top Picks

#1 The Nuby Silicone Teethe-EEZ

Editors Choice  Best Silicone Teether

Material: Silicone
Color: Blue
Soft or hard: Soft
Special features: Comes with hygienic case
Theme: Fish shaped
Dishwasher safe: Yes

Hygiene is a big concern when it comes to teething toys. Shoving it into the pocket of your diaper bag doesn’t always provide reassuring results, so a hygienic carrying case like the one featured with the the Nuby Silicone Teethe-EEZ (check price on Amazon) lets you be sure your baby’s teether stays clean when you’re on the go.

The soft silicone teething toy has multiple surfaces, including bristles which are great for massaging, stimulating and soothing your baby’s sore gums as teeth are erupting. It’s free of dangerous BPA and safe for babies over three months, and the cute fish-shaped toy is easy for them to grasp.

What We Love

  • It comes with a hygienic carrying case, which is great for keeping their teething toy clean when you’re on the move
  • It’s made of soft silicone with multiple teething surfaces, so it offers comfort, is safe, and can be cleaned easily in the dishwasher

Watch Out For

  • It’s a little bit on the large side compared to some teething toys, so some three month olds may not be ready to grasp it
  • Translucent silicone toys may become cloudy after repeated runs through the dishwasher

Check Price on Amazon

#2 The Sophie La Girafe So Pure Teether

Upgrade Choice

Material: Rubber
Color: White and brown
Soft or hard: Soft
Special features: Made from natural rubber
Theme: Giraffe
Dishwasher safe: No

Animal toys are classic cute for babies, and this simple ring has both quality and a sweet vintage touch. The Sophie La Girafe So Pure Teether (check price on Amazon) is made of 100% natural rubber and is flanked by two rings with unique teething surfaces to comfort baby.

It’s a soft teether that’s easier for them to grasp thanks to its figure-8 shape, and the texture versatility lets baby massage and stimulate their gums in different ways depending on how they’re feeling.

What We Love

  • It’s made of natural rubber and food grade paints, so it’s totally safe for your baby
  • There are two teething textures available to baby, which gives them different options for soothing

Watch Out For

  • Rubber doesn’t hold up well in the dishwasher, so this pick should only be hand washed
  • Two teething surfaces are better than one, but it’s less likely to stay interesting to your baby than more dynamic teething toys

Check Price on Amazon

#3 The First Years Star Teething Blanket

Best Budget Buy

Material: Terry cloth, satin, plastic
Color: Multi-color pink, green, blue, orange, yellow
Soft or hard: Both
Special features: Doubles as a blanket
Theme: Star
Dishwasher safe: No

Being a parent means eventually amassing a wealth of baby blankets, the origins of some of which you’re no longer sure of. Any pick in that collection that does more than swaddle is a standout, and The First Years Star Teething Blanket (check price on Amazonwins here with a budget friendly price that features a cute, friendly face and plenty of opportunities for teething comfort.

There’s a textured silicone teething area as well as satiny, terry-cloth and textured areas on the five pointed blanket, which is perfect for tummy time. There’s an attached loop that makes transporting this pick easy, plus one of the points squeaks when pressed for even more sensory interaction.

What We Love

  • It’s made of natural rubber and food grade paints, so it’s totally safe for your baby
  • There are two teething textures available to baby, which gives them different options for soothing

Watch Out For

  • Rubber doesn’t hold up well in the dishwasher, so this pick should only be hand washed
  • Two teething surfaces are better than one, but it’s less likely to stay interesting to your baby than more dynamic teething toys

Check Price on Amazon

#4 The Manhattan Rattle & Sensory Teether Toy

Best Sensory Teether

Material: Plastic
Color: Multi-color purple, blue, green, orange, and red
Soft or hard: Soft
Special features: Center cube features a fun rattle
Theme: None/sensory stimulation
Dishwasher safe: No

Sensory toys are fantastic for babies in the first year. They’re busy learning how to interact with their environment, and toys that encourage motor skill development through movement and touch are ideal.

The Manhattan Rattle & Sensory Teether Toy Combo (check price on Amazon) features an easy-to-grasp jumble of soft, colorful teething tubes made of BPA-free plastic. In the center, they’re connected by a cube, which is also a rattle that encourages baby to move and shake the toy.

It encourages two-handed play, an important part of motor development for infants, and the loops keep babies exploring the toy as they teethe. The soft plastic tubes here won’t hold up to dishwasher heat, though, so stick to hand washing for this pick.

What We Love

  • The cube that connects the tubes is also a rattle, which encourages babies to explore the toy
  • There are two teething textures available to baby, which gives them different options for soothing

Watch Out For

  • It needs to be hand washed, and there are a lot of nooks and crannies to get into in order to make sure it’s thoroughly clean
  • The tubes aren’t as soft as silicone teething toys, which some babies find more comfortable

Check Price on Amazon

#5 The Maple Wooden Teether

Best Wooden Teether  Best for Natural Teether

Material: Maple
Color: Natural wood
Soft or hard: Hard
Special features: All natural, made from sustainably sourced wood
Theme: None
Dishwasher safe: No

As we’ve noted, the struggle of parents to comfort their teething babies is eternal. The Maple Wooden teething toys (check price on Amazon) have been around for a long time, but experienced a resurgence in popularity after fears about the effects of certain plastics and chemicals on children came to light. This pair of 100% sustainably sourced rock maple teething rings features a non-toxic, chemical-free finish.

They’re thoroughly sanded, and there’s absolutely no danger of splinters. One thing we love about wooden teethers like this set is how easy they are to hand-wash. You can’t run them through the dishwasher, but they’re smooth and simple to clean, and they’re not debris magnets like silicone teethers can frequently be.

What We Love

  • They won’t pick up dirt and debris as easily as a silicone teething toy, so they’re easier to clean
  • They’re a 100% natural pick, made from sustainably sourced rock maple

Watch Out For

  • They won’t melt in the dishwasher, but they will warp, so stick to hand washing for these teethers
  • They’re solid and only have a smooth teething surface, which may make them less comforting to babies than some other picks

Check Price on Amazon

#6 The Nuby Wacky Teething Ring

Best Teething Rings

Material: Plastic, cloth
Color: Multi-color red, green, blue, yellow and orange
Soft or hard: Both
Special features: Two-pack, crinkling fabric for sensory stimulation
Theme: None
Dishwasher safe: No

Bright colors and sensory stimulation won’t make teething easier on your baby, but it can provide a productive distraction as they gum their way through the pain. Nuby scores again with a two pack of Wacky Teething Rings (check price on Amazon) that feature multiple surfaces, including dual crinkly cloth tags that are fun for baby to grab and bite.

The combination of soft and hard surfaces is ideal during teething, since their level of pain may determine the way they feel best soothing. These BPA-free rainbow rings are great for babies over three months, offering just the right balance of size and stimulation.

What We Love

  • There’s multiple hard and soft surfaces for baby to chew on, which is ideal for a teething toy
  • It offers sensory stimulation to baby through bright colors, shapes, textures and sounds

Watch Out For : It requires hand washing, and the cloth portions of the toy require air drying and may take longer to dry

Check Price on Amazon

#7 The Baby Banana Toothbrush and Teether

Best Silicone Teether and Training Toothbrush

Material: Silicone
Color: Yellow and beige
Soft or hard: Soft
Special features: Doubles as baby’s first toothbrush
Theme: Banana
Dishwasher safe: Yes

Once they’ve got teeth, they’ve gotta brush ’em – but first things first. The Baby Banana Toothbrush and Teether (check price on Amazon) is made from 100% food grade silicone, which means it can be run through the dishwasher or tossed in the freezer. (Science parents would never forgive us if we didn’t mention that it can also be put in the oven, but we can probably save that for our cookware.)

The soft bristles featured on this toy offer soothing massage while baby is teething, and once teeth have erupted, it transitions into baby’s first toothbrush. It’s both comforting and cute with a shape that’s easy for your baby to grasp, and it stays useful, which makes it a great buy.

What We Love

  • It’s made of 100% food grade silicone, so it can be both frozen and washed in the dishwasher
  • During and after teething, the toy transitions into their first soft-bristled toothbrush

Watch Out For

  • While it can be frozen, it doesn’t hold cool temperatures as long as gel toys designed to offer continued coolness
  • The grasping openings are a bit large, which some younger babies may struggle with

Check Price on Amazon

#8 The Nuby Teething Mitten

Best for Travel Teether

Material: Silicone, cloth
Color: Grey and blue
Soft or hard: Soft
Special features: Worn like a mitten
Theme: Forest animals
Dishwasher safe: No

If you’ve ever handed your baby a toy while driving only to peep it on the floor in your rear view by the time you’ve turned your head around, you can appreciate why the Nuby Teething Mitten (check price on Amazon) is a travel lifesaver for moms of teething babies.

It’s a mitten that fastens comfortably to their wrist, covering their hand and providing a silicone teething surface to gum on that won’t come off or get lost or dropped.

It also prevents babies from scratching themselves, but it’s flexible enough that they won’t be uncomfortable. The mitten can be worn on baby’s left or right hand, so observing and using the one they tend to chew on more will help them grasp the concept a bit more quickly.

What We Love

  • It’s made of 100% food grade silicone, so it can be both frozen and washed in the dishwasher
  • It’s not dishwasher safe, but it IS machine washable, which is equally convenient

Watch Out For

  • Make sure the Velcro straps are fastened flush against each other, as babies may find them scratchy when they’re not
  • The silicone area on the mitten is a bit small, so as they grow, it may be less satisfying

Check Price on Amazon

#9 The Nuby Ice Gel Teether Keys

Best Freezable Teether

Material: Plastic, non-toxic gel
Color: Rainbow
Soft or hard: Both
Special features: Features cooling gel that can be frozen
Theme: Keys
Dishwasher safe: No

The instant relief of something cold on something sore is incomparable, so it’s no wonder babies flip for the Nuby Ice Gel Teether Keys (check price on Amazon). They’re filled with Nuby’s patented PurICE gel, which is designed to get cold and stay cold while also being totally non-toxic. It would be really difficult for them to break through these bad boys with no chompers, but even if they did, parents can rest assured that they’d be just fine.

There are multiple textures and teething surfaces both soft and hard, which combines with the freezability of this pick to make it one of the most versatile on our list.

What We Love

  • It can be frozen to offer extra comfort to baby, and the gel is non-toxic, so they can’t be harmed in the unlikely event of leakage
  • There are multiple soft and hard teething surfaces, which is ideal for baby’s comfort

Watch Out For

  • Because of the gel present in this pick, it may feel heavier and harder to lift for smaller babies
  • They don’t hold up to high heat well, so hand wash this toy only

Check Price on Amazon

#10 The Blue Rabbit Teething Co & Sensory Toy

Best for 3-Month-Old

Material: Silicone
Color: Rainbow
Soft or hard: Soft
Special features: Great for sensory stimulation
Theme: None
Dishwasher safe: Yes

Colorful, stimulating toys are perfect for encouraging babies to explore. There’s lots of shapes and colors to see on this BPA-free rainbow Teething & Sensory Chew Toy (check price on Amazon) from Blue Rabbit Co. It features a star and circle charms as well as silicone beads with different shapes and surfaces to offer variety to babies while teething.

It’s super soft and easy to clean, and the beads can be turned and moved to encourage small motor development. The soothing, massaging beads of the textured toy offer versatile comfort to teething babies, and the sensory stimulation keeps them coming back to play.

What We Love

  • The beads have different shapes and surface textures, which is best for baby’s comfort
  • It offers both sensory stimulation and motor skill development opportunities through motion and color

Watch Out For : The beads are strung on a thick, sturdy cord, but if it were to break, the beads would become a choking hazard

Check Price on Amazon

And Our Favorite Teething Toy is…

Simplicity often wins the day when it comes to the things our babies use most frequently. The Nuby Silicone Teethe-EEZ Teether (check price on Amazon) is budget-friendly, durable and offers baby soothing, massaging comfort through its soft silicone bristles. Not only is it super easy to clean, but it also comes with a hygienic carrying case, so it stays extra safe and clean no matter where it gets stashed – exactly the kind of versatility we need in baby gear.

Leave a Reply

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

Pin It on Pinterest