Okay, so you’ve heard about these two popular pumps, but how does the Ameda Breast Pump stack up against the industry-leading Medela Pump In Style?
Can you get away with saving some money, or will you be sacrificing too much?
In as little as five minutes you’ll know the answer and, hopefully, know how to make the best buying decision.
Side by side comparison
Let’s look at the differences between these two leading breast pumps by placing them side by side.
| Ameda Purely Yours | Medela Pump In Style Advanced | |
|---|---|---|
| Price | Check price | Check price |
| Pump Type | Electric single/dual pump | Electric single/dual pump |
| Warranty | 1 year | 1 year |
| Weight | 5.9 lbs. | 7 lbs. |
| Closed System: | Yes | No |
| Breast Shields | No | 24 mm |
| Travel Options | Microfiber shoulder bag | Microfiber On-the-Go tote bag |
| Cooler | Removable cooler bag | Cool’N Carry Milk tote |
| Ice Packs | 3 | 1 |
| Bottles | 4 | 4 |
| Plastic | BPA free | BPA free |
| Battery Pack | 6AA batteries not included | 8AA batteries not included |
| Adaptor | Yes | Yes |
Related: Spectra S2 Breast Pump Review 2021 (Almost Great!)
Ameda Purely Yours: A Quick Overview
The Ameda Purely Yours (check price on Amazon) is an electric breast pump designed for either single or double pumping.
The unit is both portable and lightweight, making it convenient for travel. It also comes with a Cool & Carry tote and ice packs for the safe storage of expressed milk.
The system is designed for you to easily adjust both suction and speed, letting you express milk quickly and avoid any unnecessary physical discomfort.
The Ameda Pump has a Proven Airlock Protection closed system which ensures breast milk will not come into contact with bacteria, mold, and viruses that can be harmful to your baby.
It also includes a Hygiene Kit Milk Collection system.
What we love
- Closed system
- Lightweight
- Dual Hygiene Kit Milk Collection System
- Adjustable suction and speed
Watch for
- Motor sounds loud
- Doesn’t include breast shields
Read our full review: The Ameda Purely Yours review
Selected features
- A system built for better hygiene: The Ameda Purely Yours is designed with a closed system. It uses the Proven Airlock Protection system and Hygiene Kit Milk Collection System to further protect your baby from mold, viruses, and other harmful bacteria.
- Convenience and portability: This system conveniently comes with everything necessary for you to pump on the go. It has a travel tote, battery pack, cooler, ice packs, and extra bottles so you can easily pump and store your milk while you’re away from your baby.
- Quiet motor for more discretion: This model has a quiet motor and pump so you can express breast milk discreetly while at work or in the company of others. This also comes in handy for night time pumping sessions while others are sleeping.
- Customizable options: The Ameda has 32 different customizable options to help make your breast pumping experience as efficient and comfortable as possible. This is convenient for when your breasts need a break from becoming sore, or when you’re in a time crunch and need to speed things up a little.
- Check parent reviews on Amazon
What makes Ameda Purely Yours better than Medela Pump In Style Advanced?
The Ameda Purely Yours may be a better choice if you’re concerned about your little one coming into contact with bacteria, viruses, mold, and other harmful germs.
The Ameda has a closed system which creates a barrier and keeps the tubing dry. This means that your breast milk stays pure.
Related: How long can breast milk sit out?
Medela Pump In Style Advanced: A Quick Overview
The Medela Pump In Style Advanced (check price on Amazon) is a portable, electric breastfeeding system that can be used for either single or double pumping.
It has speed and suction adjustments, as well as Two-Phase Express Technology and one-touch let-down, so you can pump quickly when time is short.
The system has fully customizable settings and accessories so you can adjust pumping to suit your needs.
The single-knob vacuum and speed adjustments and PersonalFit Breast Shield sizes can make breast pumping time far more comfortable.
The removable pump is built into the microfiber bag for easy travel. It also comes equipped with all your travel needs, including a cooler and ice pack, battery pack, and extra bottles that are all tucked conveniently inside the bag.
What we love
- Two-phase express technology for fast pumping
- Built-in pump can be removed from the bag
- Designed for heavy use
Watch for
- Open system
- Heavyweight
Read our full review: Medela Pump In Style Advanced review
Selected features
- Always ready to go: The Medela Pump In Style Advanced comes with everything you’ll need to head out the door, from the microfiber bag with built-in and removable pump, to bottles and lids. The extra cooler and ice pack will ensure that the precious milk you’ve expressed will stay cool until you can safely store it in the refrigerator.
- Fast pumping for musy moms: This pump was designed for busy moms. Not only does it allow you to pump both breasts at once, but also has a Two-Phase Expression with one-touch let-down mode so you’ll be able to pump faster than a standard breast pump.
- More milk expressed: The Medela pump is a heavy-duty system that can handle numerous sessions throughout the day. This will be a relief if you’re concerned about having enough milk stored away. Breastfeeding and pumping can take its toll on any mom. This system is designed to mimic a baby breastfeeding to ensure that all your efforts will result in plenty of stored milk.
- Plastics safe from BPA: All parts that come into contact with your breast milk are made of BPA-free plastic. BPA plastics have been linked to various health issues and may be harmful to babies.
- Check parent reviews on Amazon
What makes Medela Pump In Style Advanced better than Ameda Purely Yours?
If you’re looking for a pump that offers both double duty and heavy duty, you may want to consider the Medela Pump In Style Advanced over the Ameda Purely Yours.
The Medela has special expression and let-down features, plus speed and suction adjustment options, that lets you pump several times a day without loss of suction.
Related: Spectra S2 Vs Medela Pump In Style (2021 Comparison)
Which is right for you?
The Medela Pump In Style Advanced (check price on Amazon) is easily the better breast pump and, naturally, you pay a premium for this.
This system was built to handle repeated breast-pumping sessions on a daily basis. Its heavy-duty build, portability, and quick milk-pumping capabilities make it easy to choose over the Ameda Pump.
While being able to pump quickly and repeatedly every day is very appealing, I do have some reservations about it being an open system.
The Ameda Purely Yours (check price on Amazon) may not compare with the heavy-duty abilities of the Medela Pump but does offer crucial hygiene assurances with its closed system.
If concerned about budget and, more importantly, child-health issues, then you might opt for the closed-system Ameda Pump.
