Spectra S2 Breast Pump Review (Almost Great!)

Reviewed by Nicole Lee, MPH, RN, CEN, TCRN, CLCWritten by Neve Spicer Updated on April 19th, 2023

We only include products we know and trust. If you buy through links on this page, we may earn a small commission. Learn more about our review process.

The Spectra S2 electric breast pump is one of the most popular on the market. You’ve probably heard of it (otherwise, you wouldn’t be here!), but should you buy it? That is the question we’re going to answer.

We’ll take a thorough but speedy look at what makes the Spectra S2 tick. Hopefully, after 5-minutes, you’ll know whether this electric breast pump is the right choice for you and your baby.

Product summary

The Spectra S2 (check price on Amazonis a hospital strength electric breast pump that can be used as a single or double pump. This lightweight model also has a closed system with a letdown mode which prevents bacteria from coming into contact with the breast milk.

Included in Kit:

  • Hospital grade single/double breast pump
  • 12 volt AC adaptor
  • 2 backflow protectors, duckbill valves, and tubing
  • 4 flanges
  • 2 wide neck bottles
  • 2 breast shields
What we love
  • A lightweight model at only 3 lbs.
  • Quiet performance
  • Closed system which lowers a risk of bacteria
  • Affordable price
Watch for
  • Not so feasible for heavy duty use
  • Has no battery pack

Related: Spectra S2 Vs Medela Pump In Style (2021 Comparison)

Features & benefits:

  • The unit has a closed pumping system: This system keeps the tubing dry by preventing air flow between the breast milk and pump tubing, thus preventing harmful molds and bacteria from accumulating during the pumping process. Since you have many other things to worry about when it comes to your baby, a closed breast pumping system means that you can check this one off the list.
  • BPA and DEHP Free: While many other plastics may contain these harmful substances, Spectra parts and storage containers are all BPA and DEHP free. You can rest at ease knowing that your little one will not be subjected to harmful plastic while feeding.
  • Quiet pumping: Even though we  would prefer to live in an era when breastfeeding and pumping are a perfectly natural and normal habit, unfortunately this is not always the case. The quiet motor of this system may help you feel a little more relaxed and comfortable when having to pump in a public setting such as work.
  • Single and double: This model comes with a few extras to make a new mom’s life a little easier. It has the option of pumping either one breast or both at the same time. This can be handy in a time crunch!
  • Night-time pumping: It also comes equipped with a nightlight. I know exactly how it feels to stumble about in the dark while the rest of the world sleeps. Having a nightlight on the pumping system means that you can take care of those middle-of-the-night sessions without disturbing others.
  • Adjustable modes: Gentle breast massage before pumping signals the brain that it’s time to begin breastfeeding. The system has a letdown mode that takes care of this for you, providing an easier and quicker breast pumping experience. You can also adjust the speed and suction to help you reach the most comfortable and convenient breast pumping experience. Suction can be adjusted in both the expression and letdown modes.

Assessing the competition: How does the Spectra S2 compare to other leading brands?

Our opinion

The Ameda Purely Yours (check price on Amazon) is portable and comes with a shoulder carrying bag, milk tote, cooler, and ice pack. If you are a mom on the go, then you may want to consider this pump as an option over the Spectra S2. Both models have a closed system to prevent bacteria from coming in contact with breast milk.

Read our full review: Ameda Purely Yours Breast Pump (2021 Review)

Our opinion

This system has a convenient travel tote, along with cooler and ice pack. The Medela Pump (check price on Amazon) is ideal for moms that are not only on the go but also in need of fast, double pumping to save time. The only thing to keep in mind is that the Spectra S2 has a closed system, while the Medela Pump has an open system.

Read our full review: Medela Pump In Style Advanced review

Our opinion

The Quiet Expressions Pump (check price on Amazonmay be a good alternative if you are living on a tight budget. This affordable double electric breast pump has everything a new mom needs to begin breast pumping without breaking the pocketbook. It even comes with a carrying tote, adaptor, and bottles.

Related: How to Reheat Breast Milk Safely

Who should buy a spectra s2?

 There are several things moms carefully consider when making choices that have to do with their lives and their children. These include safety, time management, efficiency, and affordability. The Spectra S2 (check price on Amazon) fits the bill where all of these are concerned.

If you are concerned about your baby and harmful bacteria, are looking for an affordable breast pump, have the desire to feel comfortable and at ease while pumping in your workplace, and want to save time by double pumping, then the Spectra S2 may be the pump you’re looking for.

Expert Note:

Most breast pumps have motors that are designed to last for about a year of heavy duty use (pumping multiple times a day, every day). A failing motor will mean less output with each pump session, as the suction gets less effective. So if you’re a regular pumper, it’s definitely a good idea to get a new pump with each new baby!

Things to know before buying a breast pump

There are a few things to take into consideration before making your electric breast pump purchase. One of the first things is comfort. As a mom, I can personally attest to this. During the period of breastfeeding and pumping, a mother’s breast go through a lot. The last thing that you want to deal with is even more pain and tenderness. It’s important that you get the right size breast shields to avoid damaged and sore nipples.

Another important thing to remember is never to buy a used breast pump or share one with others. Breast milk can carry viruses and bacteria and can also cause contamination to pumps. While it may be tempting to buy a hand-me-down or borrow a used pump from a friend, we highly advise you to purchase a new pump.

Reviewed by Nicole Lee, MPH, RN, CEN, TCRN, CLCWritten by Neve Spicer Updated on April 19th, 2023

Pin for later

Spectra s2 Breastpump review